I think you might really get something out of having a little look at my thread and looking at the comparisons between the PPA ratings (the stars), and the actual PA, (the number). Do you mind if I ask if that's your channel @fc.cadonior just someone you like watching? content may be reproduced without permission. What happens if I reduce/increase the club reputation both before preview and after? What is the difference in terms of development, between a player spending a season in the U19's and the same player spending a season in the U23's? I sign everyone from my youth intake every year, and I know for a fact that some of these players, after a year or maybe two, will all of a sudden have a lot higher PA than on youth intake day. In this case it tells me that this "has the potential to be a real golden generation for the club". [/End rant mode] Or does it mean the position that the HoYD would prefer to play the player in? Whether you're looking for tips or you're experiencing the big day for the first time, we've got all the info so you can be prepared for youth intake day in FM22. (Except for penalty taking. I'm not sure about the exact amount, but it cost me around $2M every time I upgraded with an Argentine first division club. 7. For example I'm sure there are absolutely LOADS of people who are unaware that Average/Adequate on Junior Coaching is the wrong way round. A golden generation is in comparison to previous youth intakes. After all, a L20 Training Facility is a flippin enormous investment. In terms of player development is there an experiment that we could run that would compare development of players who stayed in the U19's, players who were given a couple/few outings in the 1st Team, and the same player going out on loan at a lower level? Youth Intake - An In-depth Guide on How Clubs Produce Newgens Passion4FM Trending The Unbelievable 4-2-3-1 Football Manager 2023 Tactic feat. I certainly plan on looking at Nationalities at some point, (but was thinking more along the lines of staff Nationalities & Club Affiliations. 5. 18. I recently saw a Youtube video from [Name redacted], (because this isn't about them), about Youth Intakes and I was absolutely astonished by some of the rubbish that was being spouted. I think it would help to see the total PA & CA of the intakes as well as the basic number of players. What is clear though is that before the intake date there is nothing locked in. Highest PA 170. Youth intake day signals the arrival of 'newgens' - players that were not previously in the game but have been generated and enrolled by SI. They might be kept around to flesh out the U19's or the U23's, but every time I look at them I know they're just a filler and I don't care about their development. Some lower division intake was observed on January. It says those numbers are organised due to players preferred role. This is simply an error that SI made when these levels were introduced, but for whatever reason they have decided not to correct the order in Junior Coaching. Whilst assessing your own youth intake is the first port of call, it's always worth scouting around to see if you can steal any potential wonderkids from under the noses of rival clubs. Something that In have certainly been guilty of in various issues of FM is assuming that how things worked in 1 issue of the game, is how they would work in subsequent issues of the game. Im mostly done in like year 2040 after real players expire theyre careers. Both currently at CA two stars. Looking at your situation, (and assuming these are real players I don't know either), I would ignore the staff advice and think for yourself. It's only 14 mins long and he deals with 4 slightly different topics and even came up with a conclusion that surprised him, so rather than ignoring it or just blindly accepting it, (he was using quite a small sample size), he actually created a test to work out if the experiment was correct or if his initial assumption had been correct all along. Now obviously this is what I "think" (or more accurately, what I've heard) rather than provable fact, but from what I understand, the development priorities are: <18 - training is more important for development, so if you have better facilities it's better to keep them in youth squad for their development (assuming not good enough to play, at least as sub for first team). Below that I don't understand at all how it works. 39/64 47/57 39/88 35/63 51/62 48/74 37/108 59/74 39/80 46/84 His PA ranges from 57-108 which again doesn't fit into any single range and actually has to be spread over 4 different ranges. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. Did you know all these tips?LIKE \u0026 SUBSCRIBE Like this video to help more people find it Subscribe to get notified of our new videos - http://bit.ly/fmscout-youtube Click the bell icon and select 'All' to not miss anythingBe sure to follow Jake's own channel and Twitter - See his FM22 Newcastle save here! Jake's channel https://www.youtube.com/c/JakeCooperFM Jake's Twitter https://twitter.com/JakeCooperFM1#FootballManager #FM22 #YouthIntakePre-purchase FM22 \u0026 get your Steam key much cheaper than Steam store. That's by no means an exhaustive list, but it gives us a starting point. Want to know how to get the best young superstars in the country? . This is of course, added on top of your own modifiers such as Junior Coaching and Youth Facilities. (102 players contracted at the moment). Just for the sake of putting it on record and to confirm that I have checked it, I will also list the things that are fluid and change from save to save. What happens if I edit the Training Facilities/Youth Facilities both before the preview and after? Henrique Simal. Youth Development is a massive part of everyone's Football Manager save. The chances are that you will already know how the (Pro), (Amb) & (Det) tests turn out, but the Morale thing is a little different so might be worth checking out. Football Manager 2022 - Youth Intake Guide, How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake, Free-transferrable Players (by 2021) Shortlist. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. I say that with special reference to the fact that we know that the "Youth Intake Preview" is a relatively new addition as a feature, so if they changed that what else have they changed. Santander Bank branch locations in Funes, Spain with addresses, opening hours, phone numbers, and more information including directions, maps, and nearby locations. The last true golden generation for Dynamo Kyiv was incidentally also a class of 92-93. Liam chose to join FM22 as a striker, so unsurprisingly the virtual Liam Kemp has been a regular fixture on goal graphics across the world. Jimbokav1971, May 31, 2022 in Challenges, Sign-Ups & Experiments. (Perceived PA). You're correct though. Because I always struggle with the thought process that surely sending my star of the future to play regularly for a club with worse staff / training facilities and teammates is really going to improve them as a player? Today, Jake takes a look at how you can improve youth intakes in FM2023 so you can. It is commonly believed that the 1st intake of each save, (for all clubs), is boosted for some reason. I think we are all guilty of working hard to understand how something works and then just assuming that it will stay the same. Then we have our affiliates, (we have 7), 2 of which are in playable leagues. Football Manager newgens are the AI-generated young players that start to populate the game after the first in-game season. Is it hard work? 6. In this instance, and usingHenrique Simal andHenrique Honorato as examples just because they have 2 names which makes them stand out, let's look at their CA/PA. It's tempting to stay with so many good youngsters but this is #journeyman #FM21 https://t.co/imx8yjr1Xu" Though sorry it evolved from you getting annoyed at someone else's lack of candour online. 26.24Control Group Average PA. 73.09Minimal Facilities Average PA. 33.01. with that kind of honed in searching, finding a quality player to fill your team's needs should be doable. This was how it had been explained and this is how we understood it to work. 2. This isn't the players in your Youth Team or players on Youth contracts no matter what squad they are in. I'm playing Youth Only and messing about with my GK upfield and not mentoring players in order to make the game more of a challenge. Henrique Honorato. A high PA young player with decent CA is likely to be a decent candidate for staying at the club and playing senior football. Plus medical staff to try and ensure my hot prospects are as protected from injury as possible. So they are being rated against how good your existing players are now rather than how good they might become in the future. We have Total CA and Total PA for each player 3 and 4 from the right. 9. Absolutely nothing is static. These were obtained from the game itself and cross-checked between different saves, so were absolutely certain that theyre correct. Thanks. @Mandy42 As a result I have 2x 18 year old DR's 1x 21 year old DR, 1x 22 year old DR and a 23 year old DR. Once I have developed them I will either loan them out or sell them to generate income, but the big thing is I have to develop them 1st so that when and if I do need to go and buy someone, I will know that I have these 5 right backs that I have developed to a level that they can all come in and do a job for us. in one of my saves . Get the best HoYD . What can change? I am FAR from an expert. We had just 2 days of intake, for some reason. 4. While Azeez is guaranteed three and a half, with a possible advancement to four and a half. A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. Support FM Scout. Best FM22 Wonderkids FM22 Players Under 25 FM22 Transfer Budgets FM22 Youth Facilities Graphic Megapacks Cut Out Facepack V2023.06 - 10 Feb 2023 . More than them staying in my U23 team where they use training facilities and staff I have control over the quality of. Plus after a little research the only player of Man Utds "class of 92" to go out on loan was Beckham in 1995, where he played all of five games for Preston North End. Optimising Youth Intake I have a little trick that I use and it involves putting a "." These will increase the prospect of a 'golden generation' or two for your club, but you won't get quality players every. 3. Youth Recruitment is a club's network of information and ability to recruit young prospects. 8 players at 120+ PA. The cost will appear as "Ground Maintenance". Thanks. This seems simple doesn't it. 8 players at 120+ PA. In the instance you describe it's actually quite an awkward experiment to run, (but I'm going to add it to the list anyway because I think it's a decent question that needs answering). The yearly Youth Intake is a moment a lot of managers love. I love this and will follow the results here with much interest! The section also allows you to filter the list even more, with a very handy Nations dropdown menu under the Filter button. (We know that the attributes change, including the hidden attributes, so it makes sense this would be fluid too). If you have any particular area that you would like me to look at then please feel free to mention it. Filling out the squads is a no brainer to me. We have Average CA and Average PA for each player on the far right. 1. I "think"* what happens now is that the player rates your player against the player at your club best able to play in that position, (and how good he is in that position rather than how good he is in his best position). 16. Each year, the FM community spends countless hours improving every part of their youth setup to get the best youth intakes, but it can still be a tricky thing to master. Nothing is static. A high PA young player with decent CA is likely to be a decent candidate for staying at the club and playing senior football. One, he can pass on his Personality to your new players. Prince Ekpolo FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes, Alfons Serra FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes, Andr Seruca FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes, Tho Vermot FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes. It's just different. 8 players at 120+ PA. This guide will give you some tips to improve your yearly youth intake in Football Manager. A Head of Youth Development will affect new players in two ways. This is aged group players who are at the club but who haven't yet come through the intake. You can also supplement your youth intake by recruiting more established young players on professional contracts as part of a general youth focus. We've won the title in 3 of the last 5 seasons, (finishing 2nd and 6 the other 2 seasons), and sit 5th with 9 games remaining this season. Football Manager 2022 is here, which means it's time to dust off your suit and tie and get ready for another rollercoaster season. This is where the Youth players train at the club BEFORE they come through the intake. I am sure that certain cities will have certain nationalities come through. The member of staff that is responsible for selecting the players to appear in your youth intake, as well as inform you of it, can be configured in the Staff Responsibilities. Before I tell you what affects your youth intake, it's better you understand how they're made in the first place. Even clubs like Ajax, Barcelona and Manchester United famed for their youth system rarely promote 2 or 3 players each year who can consistently feature in their first team. #FM22Challenge #FM22 #FM22_Journeyman #footballmanager2022 #footballmanager" I could do 100 or 1,000 but I just don't have the ability/knowledge to automate the reports that this would require. (I "think"* that a staff member on the favoured personnel list influences the make-up of a plyer, but I don't know how). But good to see an experiment on it, does the size of town/city and location (ie port) have an effect on FGN nationalties and 2nd nationalities. There are 8 levels of Youth Recruitment, and to see it, you . What happens if you compare 10 different Youth Intakes from the same preview to 10 different intakes from 10 different previews? Make sure you can take the hit to your balance before you actually upgrade your Youth Facilities. Those letters will keep going down until the youth intake actually comes in. If you aren't playing competitive football by the time you are 23 you should be asking yourself if you are at the right club (imo). The likelihood of actually generating these players will change from club to club and that is what we will explain below. 12. One of the largest Football Manager Communities/Forums on the internet. Another well known youtuber pushed out a development video a couple of weeks back, where they've done multiple simulations to measure development U18s training and over 18s matches. http://bit.ly/buy-fm22Football Manager videos you can learn something from. What happens if I edit the Nationality of all staff both before the preview and after? We have continued on from the initial Youth Intake preview to the full Youth Intake Day, and now we have gone back to the previous day 9 times to give us 10 different intakes all from the same preview. The level in that Youth Team at the time was ridiculous, (when you think that the likes of Keith Gillespie, Robbie Savage, Chris Casper, Ben Thornley John O'Kane, Kevin Pilkington, Simon Davies, (no, not that one), and a few others that I can't remember), all went on to have decent Pro careers it's absolutely ridiculous. A Head of Youth Development with Catenaccio as his Tactical Style will often train new players with the Libero role and one with a 5-3-2 as his preferred formation will often produce defensive midfielders and wingbacks. 17. I have lots of questions and I will try too go through all of them between now and when FM23 comes out, (it's going to take a while), so I may start listing them. If a couple move into the U23s as backup, and another one makes the 1st team, you're doing well. This is a great topic ! What happens if you edit the CA of the existing players up/down? Click on the drop down menu, open the Facilities tab, and select "Improve Youth Facilities". An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. Training Facilities allowed players at the club to improve, Youth Facilities allowed the Youth players, (not yet through the intake), to improve, Junior Coaching largely impacted on Newgen CA and Youth Recruitment largely impacted on Newgen PA. In this case I have an idea for editing the staff members to extreme personalities and then tracking how this impacts on players who come through the intake with them on their favoured personnel list, but that's a long way away at this stage). I have maxed them out completely and given them State of the Art Training Facilities, (and left the others all at 1). PPM's. This will happen from time to time even when they have the best rating of 20 in judging player ability and judging player potential. I would love to do even a very basic/limited experiment in this area so I will add it to the list. Total CA/PA for the whole intake is definitely something I will add. . Im upping this because I barely scratched the surface on FM22, (was too into my save), but already in FM23 I have questions that need answering. Much more than any of them! Both of these contribute to the potential for wonderkids and overall good youngsters. Whether he's right or wrong doesn't matter. It's my pet hate in FM. Most of the information was correct but not everything(for example that every wonderkid would go for Portugal and not Cape verde, while i produced three wonderkids and they all became Cape Verde internationals. Secondary Nation players in other circumstances is something that could be looked at though, especially the relation with staff and affiliates. The levels of Youth Recruitment are: Let's continue with our previous hypothesis that Brazilian clubs can produce 2 S tier players, 3 A tier and 4 B tier. Highest CA 118. Media Handling style. You can take a guess of which countries have the highest game importance, e.g Argentina, Brazil, Germany, Spain, etc. We know that there are 16 players in a standard intake although this can be increased by the poaching of players from other clubs, (so if you poached 1 player from another Youth Team/Academy then you would get an intake of 17 players, but at this stage I can't remember/confirm what happens if you are the club who has a player poached. A golden generation means that the staff in charge of bringing youth into your U18 team thinks there are three or four players from the youth intake that have the potential to feature in the first team in the coming years. I've actually found it really challenging trying to manage the different squads in this save. Youth Facilities don't have any additional features or bonuses like Youth Recruitment, but keep in mind that upgrading your Youth Facilities will cost a lot of money. Every nation has a hidden attribute called Youth Rating. 10. 15. 2nd Nationality. 3 players at 150+ PA. Two First Division teams had intake Mid-November. didn't actually see this thread at the time, i think i have mentioned at times on your career thread my ideas on the youth intake. Technically speaking 2 of the MC's can also play SC, we have a 3rd MC, an AML and a GK. This should help to show something like lowering the youth facilities reducing the PA of individual players but if your Youth Recruitment is high, you're still getting the same volume of players coming through, and vice versa, do we care about youth recruitment if we're still getting high individual PA players coming through with regularity. 11. 5 players at 150+ PA. Why do low rep clubs often seem to get players from Secondary Nations in their Intakes with high PA relative to the rest of the intake? What happens if I edit the personality of all staff both before the preview and after? 18. RIght? For ages I didn't know this and I think it was possibly Cleon's Ajax thread that finally shone a light on this, (and many other things for me. It's certainly doable and is something I have thought about before. I appreciate 10 saves is a tiny number, but the truth is I just can't be bothered to do 100, (which would give great info I think). Highest CA 103. you can check out this one about comparing development. Even though you know they are not the same, you might be surprised by quite how different they can be. Looking at the Brazilian calendar, I would expect the Youth Intake preview some time in June and the Youth Intake itself some time in September, (but that's a complete guess on my part because it's a LONG time since I managed here). Enormously!!!! 5. -10 170-200-95 160-190-9 150-180-85140-170-8 130-160-75 120-150-7 110-140-65 100-130-6 90-120-55 80-110-5 70-100-45 60-90-4 50-80-35 40-70-3 30-60 (The personality has to change because all the personalities are variable). As a result of this, you will see more 4 and 5 star potential players from your youth team when you are managing in the lower leagues. Or is that what is best for the player? As the club we're experimenting with in Spain is actually Melilla, (who are based on the African mainland), I would expect to see more Africans and certainly more Moroccans, but whether that's incorporated into the game I don't know. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. As we have seen, the golden generation tag given to a youth intake is largely tied to the quality of your first team. If you think about France for example, when you think about borders, a Southern based French location should generate more Spanish & Italian Nationalities & 2nd Nationalities, with perhaps more Belgian, Dutch & German being seen further North. It will be interesting to see how that translates to the actual intake itself. Powered by Invision Community. For that you have to look at where this info comes from.. To start off with you have to check which staff member has been allocated responsibility in this area, (and change it if needed). Just like last season, 10 intakes for each simulation is tiny, but it's better than 1 intake and the truth is that I just can't be bothered to do more. 7 players at 120+ PA. Or would it be possible to get a 200 PA player from just rerolling enough times on YI day? We have 16 players in the intake (down the left hand side). Yeah, it bloomin is, but it's just the nature of the save and whether it's any more or any less hard work than looking through pages and pages of scout reports I'm not completely sure. We were expecting 32 in total, (so 16 approx in each section). 2. Let's take Beckham as an example because you mentioned him. 8. Mika Biereth an 18 year old forward and Miguel Azeez 19 year old midfielder. I think the basic experiment to track that would be 10 different Youth Intake Days from 10 different Youth Intake Previews. Newgens are completely unique players, rather than replicas of retired players. What caught my eye previously, but especially in the last results, was how many times the CA or PA ended in a 0, (so 10, 20, 30, 40 etc etc etc). It covers from 15 to 30 years old. A 10% chance. Also, if there is anything that you think I have done wrong, or if you think I'm drawing the wrong conclusions from something then just let me know. TBF there are a lot of really good young players at the club. We were expecting something close to 32 and we actually got 82, (256% bigger than we expected). If you are on twitter then bookmarking this tweet might be of help, (at least until Elon turns the lights out). You have a 1 in 10 chance of a CA or PA ending in a 0. I'm not sure that Geographic location will be used like this, but then again it seems pretty reasonable. Unfortunately, there is nothing you can do to modify this value, outside of editing with the in-game editor and other cheats. i checked this many times and sometimes by doing this you can get a golden generation even when your youth intake preview is bad. Highest CA 95. day to find the players you want like last year. 82? He was absolutely being "Driven by the evidence". The thing is though, I still have to use it correctly, (and I wasn't to start off with and I don't think a lot of people do). Because my current save is a second attempt at the Alex Ferguson challenge. Highest PA 167. It is commonly believed that the 1st intake of each save, (for all clubs), is boosted for some reason. One of the hardest things in Football Manager - after not putting your fist through the screen when you concede a 95th minute equaliser against Luton - is learning how to develop youth players in FM22. It's not my channel, but something which I like to watch. Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. By If two clubs have identical Youth Recruitment, then the club with the highest Reputation will get the better players and will get their Youth Intake day first. @Parmie Let's say Brazil (the country with the highest Youth Rating) has the potential to produce 2 S tier players, 3 A tier and 4 B tier and a bunch of other lower tier players. The last thing I would say though is that the CA/PA stars lie. With the rise of Fm22 Tips Youth Intake Football Manager 2022, many people are beginning to use them as an alternative to cars. It's relative to the players you have at your club already. Despite producing a 90 PA player, (in intake 6), it trailed the Min. Home of exclusive FM tools \u0026 the Scouting Platform. Then SI told us that things had changed and that all the facilities had an equal impact on the production of Newgens and things were no longer as specialised as they had been previously. 19. Check our Top Heads of Youth Development shortlist! Then you get the more uncertain road of a loan. 11. (So think of them as 11, 12, 13, 14 & 15 years olds all playing aged group football). Santander Bank ATM locations in Funes, Spain with addresses, opening hours, phone numbers, and more information including directions, maps, and nearby locations. Why do low rep clubs often seem to get players from Secondary Nations in their Intakes with high PA relative to the rest of the intake? Preferred foot. Press J to jump to the feed. Name. I will then post the info on 10 different Intakes all run with how the facilities are in the game as is, and then I will change things using the in game editor, go back and run the intake again, (10 more times) and see what gets thrown up. The easiest way to do so is by pressing CTRL+W, for as long as you havent changed your hotkeys. * It's important to differentiate between what we know and what we think so I will always try to be clear when something is just my opinion rather than something which I think is a fact and not up for debate. This stat affects the order in which Youth Intakes happen for loaded leagues, even: weve noted that the clubs with the best Youth Recruitment within a country will receive their regens first. i tried this with many teams as i wanted to check whether this works or not. That makes sense. What you can have an impact on. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. Giggs, Scholes, Butt and both Neville's never did. The staff that can be selected for the entry for Bring youth players into the club and inform you of their development is. As well as the quality of the players in each position, the quantity can also be important. Manage Settings Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. PA values ending in a 0 digit = 15 (18%). The youth intake are generally bad and unfortauntely set in stone. No offer of a new contract as yet so I'm browsing the job centre! I appreciate someone doing the research on this though, enjoying the work so far. It's really not an exact science I'm afraid. You linked me to an account rather than 1 particular video though, so if there is 1 video in question then feel free to link again. Be mindful though, if you see a player with high potential, sign them immediately before another club takes them from under your nose. We've only recently been given a B Team, (we're in 2050 now and I still haven't won the Liga Bwin), and for a while I was just keen to batter the opposition and field the strongest side I could in the B Team but now I have a different strategy. Once again I will say before delving into this, that the sample size of 10 intakes we're using here is tiny, but let's just go with it for a minute. Bringing through the next generation of world-class stars is one of Football Manager's most appealing features - youth development is a journey that takes time to get right. (Basically it's been done to death by people better at it than me and the other thing is I'm just too lazy). 10. Then you open up that inbox message I haven't got any ideas why this has come up, but it's certainly unusual. What single thing has the biggest impact on the quality of a Youth Intake? 1.5K 53K views 2 months ago FM23 Wonderkids FM23 Youth Intakes are one of the best parts of football manager. The dates that regens are added into the game are known as Youth Intake days.